The unhealthiest sandwich on Subway’s menu is the chicken and bacon ranch melt, which has 610 calories, 32 gm fat, 1,340 mg sodium and 6 gm sugar. On the other hand, Jersey Mike's original Italian sub has 940 calories with 53 gm fat, 2,351 mg sodium and 11 gm sugar, so if we're only judging by the worst offenders, Subway has the slimmer option.