One ‘Shroom burger has 550 calories, 31 gm fat, and 49 gm carbs, and only 18 gm protein, compared to the Single hamburger's 25 gm. If you're not looking to indulge at Shake Shack, and want to stick to your diet instead, you’re better off ordering classic options like a hamburger or even a cheeseburger over the 'Shroom.