Sam's Club's 11 Most Underrated Items Shoppers Love

It was 1983 when the very first Sam's Wholesale Club opened up in Midwest City, Oklahoma. Since then, the Walmart-owned membership-only warehouse giant has done nothing but expand its presence in the United States and the world, growing to become the 600 location-strong store we know today. Sam's Club is considered to be among the top three largest membership clubs in America alongside Costco and Amazon Prime, offering its estimated 69 million members exclusive deals on groceries, electronics, home improvement supplies, bulk paper products, and so much more.

Some of these millions of members have good news to share with the rest of the world's consumer base regarding their favorite wholesale store: some serious hidden-gem food items are waiting discreetly in the Sam's Club aisles. Nestled beside the bulk rolls of toilet paper, kitchen blenders, or newly-released books are some great bites that offer consumers slamming taste at great price points. From sweet bakery treats to fresh fruit to savory dips to cooking oils, here are 11 of Sam's Club's most underrated items that shoppers love.

Though the idea of purchasing any type of sushi from a wholesaler might sound initially off-putting, hear us out. When it comes to quality, things are different at Sam's Club, including regarding the celebrated seaweed and rice-wrapped dish. Most locations have their very own specialized sushi counter, where partnered chefs from the company FujiSan and teams of employees whip up everything from California rolls to dragon rolls to tempura shrimp, all doing so in-house every day. According to reviews from those who have sample the Sam's Club sushi, these carefully prepared creations are nothing short of mouth-watering.

But great taste alone is not the only attractive thing about the fresh sushi rolls from Sam's. Shoppers have noted that the employees behind the counter are largely helpful, friendly, available to answer any questions that arise, and have the ability to put together custom trays as needed. If you want an attractive, great-tasting, unique platter for your next get-together — or even just something different for lunch during the work week — you may want to consider giving a Sam's Club sushi creation a try. 

When it comes to different types of flour, the almond variety is undeniably more expensive when compared to its more standard, wheat-based cousin. Therefore, those who prefer to use it in cooking and baking can run into a bit of an expensive roadblock when they need to purchase the pricey stuff in large amounts. Cue Sam's Club, the membership shop that — according to consumers — has the best price on bulk almond flour around.

From home bakers to professional chefs, Sam's Club is routinely highlighted as one of the best options for sourcing affordable almond flour. "It's the best deal I've seen thus far for almond flour," insisted a user on Reddit, making a direct comparison to Costco's prices for the same product. 

On another thread, a baker praised the quality of one of the almond flour brands they had found at their local Sam's Club, declaring it had produced superior-looking macarons at a much lower price point. Before your next big baking day, you may want to squeeze in a trip to Sam's Club to check out its Blue Diamond, Bob's Mill, or other almond flour brands. You may not only save money collecting the necessary ingredients, but your batch of cookies might end up looking or even tasting a little better, too.

Rotisserie chickens have been a hot topic among consumers as of late, and it's thanks in large part to the world's leading warehouse retailer, Costco, and its ready-cooked birds with a cult following. Recently, however, Costco has come under fire for its skewered-and-seasoned poultry, which some eaters have described as having a chlorine-like aftertaste. Understandably, this has made many shoppers question their allegiance to the leading wholesaler's rotisserie chicken variant, which seems to have become unpalatable for many.

Thankfully, another delicious and inexpensive rotisserie chicken option is out there, and it comes from one of Costco's biggest competitors: Sam's Club. Not only is Sam's chicken reportedly free of any strange chemical undertones, but many shoppers declare that the company's ready-made whole chickens have a superior flavor all around. 

"Sams taste better!!! Hands down," declares a commenter on a recent TikTok video comparing the chickens from the two leading wholesale clubs. A notable number of consumers have expressed this opinion on other platforms, as well, with some going so far as to openly declare that the Sam's Club chicken is the winner due to its lower price and better overall taste. High praise that we daresay might just have a few shoppers making a major chicken switch. 

Kerrygold Butter is a brand of extra-creamy, extra-rich, and extra-flavorful Irish butter that is widely celebrated for its high quality. As the illustration on the packaging suggests, the butter is made from the milk of exclusively grass-fed cows, creating a wholesome aspect that consumers claim to taste. But you get what you pay for, of course. Good as it is, Kerrygold also harbors a bit of a reputation for being a pricey golden spread.

But thanks to Sam's Club, you may not have to break the bank just to pay for your favorite butter. Currently, sitting comfortably in the wholesaler's cold aisle, you can find a large package of 6 individual 4-ounce Kerrygold sticks. Though the exact price of the product varies according to location and club, it's the best there is according to shoppers. "Went to Sam's Club solely because they have the best price on Kerrygold. 6 sticks for $9. Might as well stock up!" raves a user on Reddit, posting a photo of an impressively tall stack of Kerrygold packs cradled in their arms. Similar claims regarding cheaper Kerrygold at Sam's exist on other platforms, as well, leading us to conclude that the wholesaler should be on your list of stops if you're a fan of this particular celebrated butter.

Arguably one of the most-used ingredients in many a home kitchen is olive oil. The rate at which many home cooks utilize it can quickly cause the money spent on the coveted cooking constituent to rack up. Thankfully, bulk wholesalers give olive oil consumers the ability to save some money and make less frequent trips to the store in search of more.

When it comes to the Sam's Club's variety of olive oil, customers happily report that they have received the best of all three cooking oil attributes: taste, price, and size. The Member's Mark 100% Pure Olive Oil comes in a gigantic 3-liter jug and is advertised as having a mild flavor. Note, however, that it is not advertised as extra virgin olive oil, which a dive into the untold truth of olive oil indicates has different applications than other varieties of olive oil.

"I like Member's Mark (Sam's Club) mild olive oil for general cooking if I'm going to use olive oil," said one user on Reddit. "It's quite cheap for olive oil, and the flavor is more muted, which I prefer in this context." The lower price point on the oil is verified many times over on other discussion threads. "The main thing I buy at Sam's club is olive oil. It's at least $5 cheaper than anywhere," shared another Sam's Club shopper. Given the combination of great flavor and excellent price, a trip to Sam's sounds more than worth it in this case.

To develop a comprehensive list of understated products that Sam's Club customers find irresistible, we sourced a variety of reviews from Reddit, TikTok, and personal shopping blogs. These varied yet consistent opinions helped us to create a collection of food items we believe that we can accurately label as well-loved. 

That said, please keep in mind that preferences are always subjective, prices can vary according to location, and individual experiences may differ.